Wages Are Up, But Many Still Rely on Government Assistance; Express Experts Cite Transportation, Childcare, Healthcare as Key Barriers
Wages are on the rise with major employers announcing higher starting wages, but for some Americans, that’s not enough to join the workforce or work more hours. Express Employment Professionals franchise owners report that many Americans who rely on government assistance to cover household costs do not yet see an incentive to take on a job.
One of the key reasons, as Express reported in a previous white paper, is many benefit programs are structured in such a way that earning slightly more money can trigger a dramatic decrease in benefits. A working single parent can find a job that pays more money but could also pay an effective marginal tax rate of up to 80 percent on those new earnings.
“We see a lot of government benefits creating a disincentive to work,” said Luke Sodergren, an Express Employment Professionals franchise owner with offices in Michigan and Wisconsin. “Some potential workers see the benefits as ‘free money’ and don’t want to turn it down in favor of a job.”
Sodergren observes that even though wages have drastically gone up in his area, it has not changed the thought process of those deciding between welfare and work.
“Health benefits are a major factor,” he said. “Why would an employee take a job and pay for benefits when they can get them for free?”
Transportation and childcare are two other major hurdles that keep people from taking a job and transitioning off government assistance.
“Ridesharing is a good idea,” Sodergren said. “I know of a company that picks people up from all sorts of cities at park-and-rides and they all take a van to work together. In our area, a lot of people are also not able to afford daycare. Companies will need to be more flexible with families and maybe offer some kind of supplemental child care.”
Terri Greeno, an Express franchise owner in Crystal Lake, Illinois, sees many of the same issues.
“We struggle with this constantly,” she said. “A single mom with two kids can earn the equivalent of $12/hour of government assistance for food and housing. Why would she go through the hassle of finding and paying for daycare for her children to accept a position with an entry-level wage?”
However, rising wages still are not enough.
“We have seen increasing wages for about two years now,” Greeno said. “Although they’ve increased, it isn’t necessarily enough to engage the disengaged workforce.”
Greeno also cites the importance of transportation and child care in helping people transition into the workforce.
“Perhaps companies could offer some type of a subsidy to help offset the cost of daycare,” she said. “Benefits that are affordable and can help parents provide medical care for their children are a valuable perk. Transportation may help as well.”
“Everyone who wants to work should have the chance to do so; it provides purpose and dignity and a chance for upward mobility and a better life,” said Bill Stoller, Express CEO. “But the structure of government benefit programs can be a disincentive. After all, who wants to work more hours and earn virtually nothing more? Assistance programs have a vital purpose, but we all have a stake in making sure that they don’t keep people who can work or want to work from pursuing a career.”